Ethics
Archived Posts from this Category
Archived Posts from this Category
Posted by Caitlin on 14 Nov 2008 | Tagged as: Blogging, Ethics, Europe, Trends
In my first post for environmental blog EcoSalon, I write about Cornwall - a stylish choice for an eco-holiday.
I have some exciting news to share - I’m joining EcoSalon as a regular contributor. I’ve been asked to write two posts a week, one on green travel and one on green tech and lifestyle.
My first post is on eco-holidays in Cornwall, looking at walking, food, art and destinations such as the Eden Project. Cornwall is one of my favourite parts of Britain and, as I hope my photos show, an extremely beautiful part of the country. The post was published today and I’m delighted that it’s currently featured as the EcoSalon Daily Favourite right at the top of the site. Please take a look and let me know what you think. Leave a comment either here or on EcoSalon and if you like it, please feel free to share the link with your friends.
The theme of EcoSalon is about going green without sacrificing style and this is something that really strikes a chord with me. Readers who are familiar with this blog and my food blog The Gooseberry Fool might know that I am a passionate environmentalist. However, I also believe that people need inspiration and a reason for hope. We shouldn’t hide from the immensity of the challenge – but if we focus on doom and gloom, we risk generating despair rather than the committed and focused action the planet needs. Despair is just as destructive to the environment as denial.
I’m pleased to be blogging for EcoSalon because the blog is committed to the environment but with an aim to empower and inspire people rather than hector or scare them. There’s enough troubling environmental news out there – the question is what we can do about it.
Lest any fans of Roaming Tales be fretting about the future of this site - never fear! I fully intend to keep my own site and my blogging duties at EcoSalon are as well as, not instead of, what I already do. It’s a paid gig so this properly falls into my day job as a freelance writer.
Posted by Caitlin on 10 Nov 2008 | Tagged as: Africa, Asia, Ethics, Europe, Events, Trends
Congratulations to BeWILDerwood, Africa’s Eden and Ngong Ping 36O and all the award-winning travel writers.
I have been a member of the British Guild of Travel Writers for about a year now. It’s a professional organisation and you are only eligible to join if you can demonstrate that you are making a living substantially from travel writing, whether that be books or articles. Membership entitles you to have your name listed in the Year Book, which goes out to all members and other industry professionals who pay to receive it, and use of the snazzy new website where you can build a mini-website or network virtually with other members. You also get a membership card and various discounts but I think the biggest benefit is the opportunity to network with other writers and travel professionals at the regular Guild events.
The star event on the Guild calendar, apart from the AGM, is the annual awards dinner. It was hosted last night at the Marriott in Grosvenor Square and it was a great night. We started with a champagne reception with Jersey oysters and then moved into the main room for dinner. The food at awards events can often be a bit rubbish but last night’s meal was really good - it was a collaboration between the Marriott’s restaurant Maze (part of the Gordon Ramsay empire) and the island of Jersey (one of the sponsors), so we had Jersey crab for starters and Jersey vegetables with our lamb for main course, and Jersey cream with our dessert.
There were actually two sets of awards - the Tourism Awards where members vote on the best tourism projects around the world and the Members Awards for travel writing published in the past year. The Tourism Awards were announced before dinner, the Members Awards between starter and main course and then the raffle (to raise money for the Back Up Trust, a spinal injury charity) before dessert.
I’d come along to a Guild meeting a few months ago to hear the nominations for the Tourism Awards and vote on the short list. The final winners were then determined by a vote of the entire membership by post and email. So I was familiar with the nominations but I didn’t know who had actually won until the night. I was really thrilled because all the projects I voted for won their categories! So congratulations to BeWILDerwood in Norfolk for best UK project, Africa’s Eden or Loango National Park in Gabon for best non-UK project, and Ngong Ping 360 in Hong Kong for best global project.
I’m almost tempted to borrow children and take them to BeWILDerwood as the description of this place really captured my imagination. It’s a treetop adventure playground - with treehouses, aerial ropewalks and zipwires, boats and boardwalks - built on 50 acres of woodland and marshland. It’s very eco-friendly - it’s all built from sustainable wood, the entire site is pesticide free, and they’ve planted a lot of trees as well. Among the magical creatures who live there are Mildred, the vegetarian Crocklebog who lives in the Scary Lake, and Swampy a March Boggle. There is nothing modern about BeWILDerwood, although the guy who built it has said he was partly inspired by 90s computer game Myst.
If it weren’t so expensive, I would book my ticket to Loango National Park in Gabon tomorrow. The fact that I can’t is partly the point - they are trying to keep tourism numbers low so that it’s sustainable for the park’s ecology and the wellbeing of the people who live there. Rombout Swanborn, the director of Loango National Park, has said: “We will never have 20 Jeeps around a waterhole shining lights into animals’ eyes.”
The president of Gabon set aside 11% of the country as a national park in 2002 - only tiny Costa Rica has preserved a greater proportion of land. Before then tourism was virtually unknown in Gabon but they began developing the industry at this point with the ethos “ecotourism pays for conservation”. Loango National Park opened in 2007, covering grassland, rivers, forest and mangroves and featuring spectacularly varied wildlife, including whales, elephants, hippos, leopards, reptiles and primates. Visitors are accommodated in the eco-friendly lodge and satellite tented camps and wildlife viewing is small-scale with pirogue trips, forest treks or savannah drives. There are 500 Gabonese in the area with nearly 100 employed as eco-guides etc, while local farmers sell produce to the lodge, and their children attend a new school built by the park.
Ngong Ping 360 in Hong Kong combines an existing attraction - the Giant Buddha built by the nearby Po Lin monastery on Landau Island - with a new one. Previously there were so many tourists coming to see the Giant Buddha and the strain on the monastery was too much, with monks spending their whole time providing refreshments. Now Ngong Ping 360 is actually bringing more tourists but they’ve actually managed to reduce the impact on the environment and the monastery. The tourists arrive via a 5.7km cable car skyrail - the world’s longest without a car change - so they didn’t have to build a road through the forest. While tourists can still climb up to see the Buddha, Ngong Ping has also built a Chinese cultural village with dining facilities, which has reduced the burden on the monastery. A win-win situation!
All Guild members are eligible to enter their work for the travel writing awards and entries are judged anonymously. The winning pieces are published in a glossy booklet, which made highly entertaining reading on my Tube ride home at the end of the night. I believe they will also be posted up on the BGTW website at some point as well. Congratulations all!
Posted by Caitlin on 30 Sep 2008 | Tagged as: Blogging, Ethics, Events, Trends
There’s a green theme to this week’s round-up of travel links.
Posted by Caitlin on 22 Aug 2008 | Tagged as: Ethics, Europe, Photo post, Trends
Jewish Cemetery, Krakow, Poland. August 2008.
As we walked from the train station in Krakow, the old royal capital of Poland, to our rented apartment, a lady handed us a tourist leaflet offering air-conditioned coach tours of various ‘attractions’ around the city. Along with the guided tours of the salt mines, one of the options was a tour of Auschwitz.
I don’t know how I feel about this. I think it’s important that we remember our history and I support the fact that the place of so much suffering has been turned into a museum. But it doesn’t feel right for it to be packaged up as just another commercial product, however sensitively it’s handled.
We didn’t end up going - perhaps another time, but almost certainly under our own steam rather than on a bus tour. However, we did take a walk through the Jewish Cemetery in Krakow. It was free to enter but the boys had to don skull caps, which reminded me of how I wore the hijab for my recent visits to mosques in Syria.
The far side of the cemetery was very overgrown with weeds and vines and many of the gravestones were framed by ferns and moss. On the near side, we saw freshly tended graves with flowers with death dates in the past 10 years - it’s amazing to think of how even a depleted Jewish population of Krakow survived through first the Nazi and then the Soviet occupation. One plaque on the wall had an English inscription, which may have been dedicated by the American descendants of a Polish Jew.
This particular gravestone struck me as interesting. The small coloured lanterns were quite common on many of the graves, but what I found interesting was the fact that the man’s name was given in both Polish and German. He died in 1946. There’s a story there, though I don’t know what it is.
PS There are some interesting clues and possibilities in the comments field.
Posted by Caitlin on 26 Feb 2008 | Tagged as: Blogging, Ethics, Trends
Posted by Caitlin on 16 Jan 2008 | Tagged as: Asia, Ethics
Tibet has always seemed a magical, mystical place to me. I saw the Dalai Lama speak in Sydney when I was about sixteen, I have seen films like Kundun and read books like Seven Years in Tibet. But I have never been to Tibet, or indeed anywhere in the Himalayas.
It seems that plenty of others have. Tibet has been hammered by high-impact tourism for several years now and in 2007 for the first time, the annual number of visitors has exceeded the total population of Tibet. Even in the best of times it would be hard for Tibetan culture to survive, let alone thrive under these circumstances. Sadly, Tibetans don’t live in the best of times.
Since 1950 when the Chinese seized control of Tibet, there has been a steady exodus of Tibetans and an equally inexorable influx of Han Chinese into this tiny Himalayan kingdom. The population of Tibet is only 2.8 million, while the population of China is close to one billion, so outnumbering the Tibetans is not a difficult task. The rule is oppressive, according to both Tibetans themselves and outside observers, and many Tibetans feel compelled to make the terrible, risky journey across the Himalayas to live in exile in Dharamsala in northern India.
Yet China has been promoting Tibet as a tourist destination. There are new air and rail links bringing in more tourists than ever before. Most of the tourist industry in Tibet is run by Chinese and the Tibetans see little benefit. The earthly paradise of Shangri-La is no longer a myth but a marketing ploy (a few years ago the Chinese authorities renamed an existing Tibetan city as Shangri-La and it’s now full of resorts and shopping malls).
As far as I can see, there’s no real way to visit Tibet as a tourist and be part of the solution, not the problem. It would make me far too sad and I don’t want to be complicit in the Chinese occupation. I would rather go to Nepal or Bhutan for the Himalayan experience, and Dharamsala for the Tibetan cultural experience. My friend Vanessa Walker has spent time in Dharamsala and wrote a rather wonderful book called Mantras and Misdemeanours, which has inspired me to make the trip one day.
If I ever do go to Tibet, I hope it will be in happier times, or to make a genuine difference to people’s lives, whether by reporting on the situation as a journalist, or with immediate, practical assistance.
Speaking of the Himalayas and making a difference to people’s lives, Antonia at Perceptive Travel has posted about the death of Sir Edmund Hillary, reminding us that he should be remembered as much for the work he did to help the people of Nepal as for the fact that he climbed Mount Everest.
Posted by Caitlin on 12 Dec 2007 | Tagged as: Ethics, Trends
The New York Times has published a list of 53 hot destinations for 2008.
I have been to the following places on the list: Laos, Tunisia, Prague, Tuscany, Oslo, Lombok, San Francisco, Detroit, Kilimanjaro, London, Las Vegas, New York. There is only one Australian destination on the list - the Barossa Valley - and I haven’t been there.
Where have you been on the list? Where do you want to go? Do you agree with their selections? What do you think will be hot in 2008?
In the UK, there is a big trend toward holidaying closer to home - it’s not so much about what’s hot, but what’s green. Do environmental concerns affect your choice of holiday destination?
Posted by Caitlin on 09 Dec 2007 | Tagged as: Ethics, South America
Peru has always held an enormous fascination for me and climbing Machu Picchu has long been on my list of things to do. But archaeologists are warning that Peru’s Incan ruins, including Machu Picchu, are straining under a tourist boom.
For a long time, travelling to Peru was complicated by the continuing struggle with the Maoist Shining Path rebels. But now it’s become the hot new destination with everyone from Cameron Diaz to Princess Beatrice visiting in the past year. In 1992, just 9,000 people visited Machu Picchu; last year it was 700,000. A former culture ministry official has said: “If we open up Machu Picchu to more tourism, the place will be destroyed within 10 years.”
The authorities have tried to limit the numbers on the hiking trail but now that means that there is a huge increase in tourists going to other ancient sites, such as Choquequirao, the partially excavated sister city to Machu Picchu, and that’s also a problem.
It makes me so sad to hear about the damage caused to our priceless historical and wilderness treasures by irresponsible tourism. I believe litter is a big problem on the slopes of Mount Everest as well. And in the Arctic, I saw lots of bits of plastic, not from tourists but washed into the Arctic Ocean from the Atlantic coasts off Europe and North America.
This makes me think twice about going to Machu Picchu. If I ever do go, I’ll be sure to book with a reputable operator that ensures benefit for the local people and good environmental practices. A site such as Responsible Travel can help me find the right one. I would also consider a volunteer vacation to ensure I’m part of the solution, not the problem.
What do you think is the solution? Should tourists stop going to Peru’s Incan sites? Should the government heavily restrict it? Already Machu Picchu is closed to hikers in February while they clean up all the garbage discarded by hikers over the previous year. I think there needs to be a wider cultural change, not just a cap on numbers.